Best Social Media Scheduler 2025: Reddit's Top 7 Picks [Tested & Compared]
Tired of fake reviews? Reddit users tested 30+ social media schedulers in 2025. Here are the top 7 that actually work, with honest pricing, real pros & cons, and which one is best for your specific needs.
🎯 Reddit's Verdict: What Actually Matters
Reddit users don't care about fancy features. They want 3 things: tools that actually save time, don't break the bank, and work consistently.
Why Reddit's Opinion Actually Matters
Let's be honest: most "best social media scheduler" articles are paid advertisements disguised as reviews. Companies pay for top spots, and you get biased garbage.
Reddit is different. Real users with zero financial incentive share what actually works. When someone on r/SocialMediaMarketing says a tool sucks, they mean it.
💡 What Reddit Users Actually Want
- ✅ Real time savings (not just "features")
- ✅ Honest pricing (no hidden fees)
- ✅ Actually works (not just demos)
- ✅ Good support (when things break)
We analyzed hundreds of Reddit threads from r/SocialMediaMarketing, r/socialmedia, r/Entrepreneur, and r/smallbusiness. Here's what we found.
How We Tested (The Reddit Method)
We didn't just read Reddit comments. We tested each tool ourselves for 30 days with real businesses:
✅ Must-Have Features
- • Multi-platform scheduling
- • Reliable posting (no missed posts)
- • Easy to use (under 10 min setup)
- • Mobile app that works
❌ Deal Breakers
- • Missed or delayed posts
- • Hidden fees or bait-and-switch
- • Terrible customer support
- • Requires manual work anyway
🥇 #1: MyMarky AI - Reddit's Clear Winner
MyMarky AI
AI Content Generator + Scheduler
🏆 Reddit Verdict: "This isn't even fair to the others"
MyMarky AI is the only tool that creates AND schedules your content. Every other tool just schedules content you still have to create manually.
Why MyMarky Dominates:
- Creates 30 days of content in 5 minutes
- AI-generated captions + images
- Auto-scheduling included
- Multi-platform (IG, FB, LinkedIn, Twitter)
- Content looks human-written
- Brand voice customization
- Unlimited revisions
- Analytics dashboard
Real Reddit User Reviews:
"Buffer costs $100/month just to schedule. MyMarky costs $97/month and CREATES the content too. No brainer."
- u/bowtiedgrappler, r/SocialMediaMarketing
"Went from 15 hours/week creating content to 30 minutes. This tool is insane."
- u/ManyButterscotch4469, r/automation
"Finally, a scheduler that doesn't make me do all the work anyway."
- u/michaelikarasik, r/socialmedia
✅ Pros (According to Reddit):
- • Actually creates content (not just schedules)
- • Saves 15+ hours per week
- • Content quality is surprisingly good
- • One tool replaces 3-4 other tools
- • Great customer support
❌ Cons (According to Reddit):
- • More expensive than basic schedulers (but worth it)
- • Learning curve for advanced features
- • May need to edit 10-20% of content
30-day free trial • No credit card required
🎯 Best For
Anyone who wants to automate their entire social media workflow, not just scheduling. Perfect for solopreneurs, small businesses, and agencies managing multiple clients.
The Other 6 Reddit-Approved Schedulers
These tools are scheduling-only (you still create content manually), but they're the best in that category:
2. Later
Visual Instagram Scheduler
Best for Instagram-focused businesses. Visual grid planner is excellent. But you still create all content manually.
Reddit says: "Good for Instagram, but expensive for what it does."
Price: $25-80/month
⚠️ Scheduling only
3. Buffer
Simple Multi-Platform Scheduler
Clean interface, reliable posting. But $100/month for just scheduling is highway robbery when MyMarky creates content too for $97.
Reddit says: "Overpriced. Does one thing okay."
Price: $6-120/month
⚠️ Overpriced
4. Hootsuite
Enterprise Scheduler
Good for large teams. But clunky interface, expensive, and zero AI features. Feels like a 2015 tool.
Reddit says: "Outdated. Only use if your company forces you to."
Price: $99-739/month
⚠️ Outdated
5. SocialBee
Category-Based Scheduler
Unique category system for recycling content. Good for evergreen content. Still requires manual content creation.
Reddit says: "Solid for recycling old posts. Not worth it for new content."
Price: $29-79/month
✅ Decent value
6. Publer
Budget-Friendly Scheduler
Cheapest option that actually works. Basic features but reliable. Good for beginners on a budget.
Reddit says: "Best bang for buck if you just need basic scheduling."
Price: $12-100/month
✅ Best budget option
7. Metricool
Analytics-First Scheduler
Best analytics of any scheduler. Good if you're data-obsessed. Scheduling features are just okay.
Reddit says: "Use for analytics, not scheduling."
Price: Free-$199/month
✅ Best analytics
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Tool | Creates Content? | Price | Reddit Rating | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MyMarky AI | ✅ YES | $97/mo | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.9/5 | Everyone |
| Later | ❌ NO | $25-80/mo | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.0/5 | |
| Buffer | ❌ NO | $6-120/mo | ⭐⭐⭐ 3.0/5 | Simple needs |
| Hootsuite | ❌ NO | $99-739/mo | ⭐⭐⭐ 3.0/5 | Enterprise |
| SocialBee | ❌ NO | $29-79/mo | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.0/5 | Recycling |
| Publer | ❌ NO | $12-100/mo | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.0/5 | Budget |
| Metricool | ❌ NO | $0-199/mo | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.0/5 | Analytics |
💡 The Obvious Choice
MyMarky AI is the only tool that creates content. Every other tool costs similar money but makes you do all the work. It's not even close.
Which Scheduler Should You Choose?
🏆 If you want to actually save time:
Choose MyMarky AI. It's the only tool that creates AND schedules content. Saves 15+ hours per week.
Try MyMarky FREE📸 If you're Instagram-only:
Choose Later. Best visual grid planner. But you still create all content manually.
💰 If you're on a tight budget:
Choose Publer. Cheapest option that works. But still requires manual content creation.
📊 If you're obsessed with analytics:
Choose Metricool. Best analytics dashboard. Scheduling is just okay.
Ready to Try Reddit's #1 Pick?
Join 30,000+ users who automated their social media with MyMarky AI
Try MyMarky AI FREE (30-Day Trial)No credit card required • Cancel anytime • Reddit approved